C.L. "Butch"
Secretary of
Brandon D
D Woolf
SCO > Board of Examiners > Board of Examiners Minutes
June 11, 2002 – 8:50 a.m.
JRW East Conference Room

Members Attending:
      Governor Dirk Kempthorne, Chairman of the Board
      Attorney General Al Lance
      State Controller J. D. Williams, Secretary of the Board

Member Absent:
      Secretary of State Pete Cenarrusa

Sub-Committee Members Attending:
      Ben Ysursa, Office of Secretary of State
      Keith Johnson, Office of State Controller

Visitors Attending:
      DuWayne D. Hammond, Jr., State Tax Commission


1. Approval of minutes for May 14, 2002 State Board of Examiners.


    Request for authorization for additional deficiency warrant spending authority in the amount of $300,000 for the 2002 Grasshopper/Mormon Cricket Control Program. The Board of Examiners approved $150,000 on February 12, 2002 and this additional funding request would bring the total to $450,000.


    Request for authorization to reimburse additional moving expenses of $2,500 for the position of Assistant Professor in the Department of Pharmacy Practice and Administrative Sciences, for a total of up to $7,500. The Sub-Committee approved $5,000 moving expenses reimbursement on March 7, 2002. The University is prepared to offer this position to a candidate at the level of Associate Professor. Reimbursement will be within the State Moving Policy regulations.


      Request for authorization to recognize a FY 2002 miscellaneous expenditure of $104.86 to properly account for funds stolen from the Rotary account in 1999. This would require changing the amount listed on the reconcilement form, under “cash on hand” from $540.00 to $565.14 reflecting the petty cash overage of $25.14. The Rotary account would once again balance to the original amount of $4,000. The theft was reported to the police by the Health District.

      Request for authorization to pay accrued compensatory time for the following employees:
          Don Wykhoff, Forensics Lab Manager/Pocatello 110.0 hours
          Michael Anthony, Forensic Scientist/Pocatello 27.0 hours
          Ben Clements, IT System Programmer 89.6 hours
          Larry McGhee, POST Coordinator/Meridian 25.0 hours
          John Turnbull, POST Coordinator/Meridian 58.0 hours
          John Parmann, POST Regional Training Coordinator 70.0 hours

      Request for approval to use Penalty and Interest monies under Idaho Code 72-1348(b) for the following:
        1) $18,000 for 2001/2002 membership dues to the National Association of State Workforce Agencies (NASWA).
          2) Final Fiscal Year 2002 state matching and supplemental funds for the Idaho Rural Partnership in the amount of $25,000. This will be the last use of Penalty and Interest funds for this purpose.
            3) Up to $20,000 per year to assist the Division of Professional Technical Education’s Career Information System (CIS).
              4) Department of Labor facility costs:
                  a. Up to $400,000 for completion of the remodel of the Department’s Lewiston Job Service office. The Board previously authorized $700,000 for this project, which was started in 1998.
                    b. Up to $150,000 for maintenance and upgrading of the HVAC system at the Department’s Canyon County Job Service office.
                      c. Up to $65,000 for re-roofing the Department’s Boise Job Service office.

                  VETERANS SERVICES

                7. Request for authorization to lift the vacation accrual cap for six (6) months (until June 30, 2002) for Patrick Teague, Veterans Services Program Supervisor. This employee is required to attend many activities sponsored by veterans’ groups including holiday celebrations honoring veterans, quarterly meetings and annual conventions. The department will continue to work with the employee to ensure that earned leave is taken.

                8. Request for authorization to pay 832.70 hours accrued compensatory time for Philip Hawkins, Volunteer Services/Activities Coordinator. Mr. Hawkins has not accrued comp time since the arrival of the new administrator in Boise in October 2001. He is encouraged to take leave but he is required to attend many events sponsored by veterans’ groups. He is currently at the maximum vacation accrual limit and is losing vacation.

                  Request for authorization to pay compensatory time, accrued to take care of several situations due to security, safety, and computer software issues due to the Year 2000 issue, for the following management staff. Correctional Industries is a non-funded state agency and this will have no impact on the general fund. Earned Administrative Leave payoff does not require Board of Examiners approval.
                    Steve Holderman CI Agricultural Products Manager 157.0 hours
                    Terry Knapp CI Production Manager 112.3 hours
                    David Fulkerson CI Accounting Manager 194.0 hours


                  Request for authorization to issue deficiency warrants for reimbursement of response costs incurred, pursuant to Idaho Code 39-7110.

                10. 2002-1079
                Drug Lab
                $ 557.46
                11. 2002-0315
                Fuel Spill
                $ 4,250.46
                Truck wreck
                12. 2002-1378
                Drug Lab
                $ 213.15
                13. 2002-1373
                Drug Lab
                $ 353.47
                $ 5,374.54

                  Ratification of the June 3, 2002 Board of Examiners approval of the transfer of $12 million from the General Fund into the state refund account so that tax refunds can be paid timely. Pursuant to Idaho Code 63-3067(4) any unencumbered balance remaining in the state refund account on June 30, 2002, in excess of $1.5 million, will be transferred back to the General fund, unless directed otherwise.

                15. OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL

                Notification that Randall A. Peterman of the firm of Elam & Burke has been appointed as a special deputy attorney general for the purpose of representing the State of Idaho in the Jefferson Grain & Seed, Inc. Bankruptcy Matter, Department of Agriculture, pursuant to Idaho Code §67-1409.


                  Request for recognition of assignment as executed by Assignor Heartland Burley, Commercial Partners, Salt Lake City, Utah, and Assignee The Fifth Amendment, Inc., an Idaho corporation, Burley, Idaho, for a lease agreement for space, Lease No. 0455, as extended by Lease Amendment December 1993 and further extended under Lease Amendment/Extension Agreement dated October 14, 1998 for the Department of Health and Welfare’s Burley Field Office Lease, pursuant to Idaho Code 67-1027.

                  ST. LUKE’S HOSPITAL
                  The Sub-Committee members’ recommendation is to deny this claim because it is felt this is not a liability of the State of Idaho.

                  Request for payment of outstanding claims in the amount of $15,322.09 to the St. Lukes Regional Medical Center (SLMRC) per Idaho Code 67-1023, as well as the amount of contractual adjustments which appear to have been taken when Correctional Medical Services did not have a contract with St. Lukes.

                18. SECRETARY OF STATE
                  Request for authorization of the 2002 Idaho Code Annual Distribution List, pursuant to Idaho Code 73-212.
                    Agency Number of Copies
                    Ada County 49
                    Adams County 7
                    Administration, Department of 6
                    Aging, Idaho Office on 1
                    Agriculture, Department of 5
                    Alabama Court & State Law Library 1
                    Arizona Department of Library & Archives 1
                    Attorney General, Office of 44
                    Bannock County 33
                    Bar, Idaho State 1
                    Bear Lake County 7
                    Benewah County 10
                    Bingham County 13
                    Blaine County 12
                    Blind, Idaho Commission of the 1
                    Boise County 6
                    Boise State University Library 1
                    Bonner County 16
                    Bonneville County 20
                    Boundary County 8
                    Building Safety, Division of 6
                    Butte County 7
                    Camas County 4
                    Canyon County 41
                    Caribou County 8
                    Cassia County 14
                    Clark County 6
                    Clearwater County 11
                    College of Southern Idaho 1
                    Colorado Supreme Court Library 1
                    Commerce, Department of 1
                    Connecticut State Library 1
                    Controller, Office of the 5
                    Correction, Department of 14
                    Custer County 6
                    Dairy Products Commission 1
                    Deaf and Blind, School for the 1
                    Delaware State Law Library 1
                    Dentistry, Board of 1
                    Disaster Services 1
                    Division of Veterans Services 1
                    Education, State Board of 1
                    Education, State Department of 5
                    Elmore County 15
                    Endowment Fund Investment Board 1
                    Engineers & Land Surveyors, Board of 1
                    Environmental Quality, Division of 7
                    Finance, Department of 2
                    Financial Management, Division of 5
                    Fish and Game, Department of 8
                    Florida Supreme Court Library 1
                    Franklin County 8
                    Fremont County 4
                    Gem County 10
                    Gooding County 10
                    Governor, Office of the 2
                    Hawaii Supreme Court Law Library 1
                    Health & Welfare, Div of Management Services 32
                    Health Districts, Central 1
                    Health Districts, Conference Office 1
                    Health Districts, District Seven 1
                    Health Districts, North Central 1
                    Health Districts, Panhandle 2
                    Health Districts, Southeastern 1
                    Health Districts, Southwestern 1
                    Human Resources, Department of 2
                    Human Rights, Commission on 1
                    Idaho County 9
                    Idaho State Library 2
                    Idaho State Police 26
                    Idaho State University 3
                    Industrial Commission 5
                    Insurance Fund, State 2
                    Insurance, Department of 3
                    Jefferson County 7
                    Jerome County 14
                    Juvenile Correction Center 1
                    Juvenile Corrections, Department of 1
                    Kansas Supreme Court Law Library 1
                    Kentucky State Law Library 1
                    Kootenai County 40
                    Labor, Department of 6
                    Lands, Department of 5
                    Law Enforcement Training 1
                    Law Library, Idaho Supreme Court 43
                    Legislative Auditor 2
                    Legislative Budget Office 3
                    Legislative Services 12
                    Legislature, House of Representatives 25
                    Legislature, Senate 18
                    Lemhi County 8
                    Lewis County 13
                    Lewis-Clark State College 5
                    Lieutenant Governor, Office of 1
                    Lincoln County 8
                    Liquor Dispensary 1
                    Local Highway Technical Assist Council (LHTAC) 1
                    Madison County 9
                    Maine Law & Leg Reference Library 1
                    Medicine, State Board of 1
                    Military Division 1
                    Minidoka County 12
                    Minnesota State Law Library 1
                    Mississippi State Law Library 1
                    Missouri Supreme Court Library 1
                    Montana State Law Library 1
                    Nebraska State Library 1
                    New Hampshire State Library 1
                    New Mexico Law Library 1
                    Nez Perce County 17
                    North Carolina Supreme Court 1
                    North Dakota Supreme Court Library 1
                    North Idaho College Library 2
                    Nursing, State Board of 1
                    Occupational License Bureau 1
                    Oklahoma Department of Libraries 1
                    Oneida County 5
                    Owyhee County 8
                    Parks & Recreations, Department of 2
                    Payette County 9
                    Peace Officers Standards & Training Academy 1
                    Performance Evaluation, Office of 2
                    Pharmacy, Idaho State Board of 1
                    Power County 7
                    Professional-Technical Education 1
                    Public Utilities Commission 9
                    Public Works Contractors License Board 1
                    Real Estate Commission 1
                    Retirement System, Public Employees 2
                    Rhode Island State Law Library 1
                    Secretary of State, Idaho State Controller's Office 4
                    Shoshone County 15
                    South Carolina Legislative Council 1
                    South Dakota Supreme Court Library 1
                    State of Utah Law Library 1
                    Tax Appeals, Board of 1
                    Tax Commission, Idaho State 18
                    Tennessee State Law Library 1
                    Teton County 6
                    Transportation, Department of 11
                    Treasurer, Office of the State 1
                    Twin Falls County 27
                    University of Idaho 33
                    University of Idaho Library 1
                    Valley County 10
                    Vermont State Library 1
                    Virginia State Law Library 1
                    Vocational Rehabilitation 1
                    Washington County 10
                    Washington State Law Library 1
                    Water Resources, Department of 4
                    Wyoming State Library 1

                Governor: The Board of Examiners will come to order. We will turn to our State Controller as Secretary of the Board to present us our report. I will note that our Secretary of State is absent and will be absent for a short period of time, having undergone back surgery. All indications are that he is doing extremely well and we are grateful for that. With that, the State Controller.

                State Controller: Governor, we have 18 items on the Consent Agenda and two items on the Regular Agenda. The Board’s Sub-Committee has met and reviewed all these items and recommends that the 18 items on the Consent Agenda be approved.

                Governor: Is there discussion? Is there a motion, General?

                Attorney General: Governor, I would move the approval of the Consent Agenda.

                Governor: I will second that. Further discussion? Those in favor please say aye.

                Aye: Governor
                Attorney General

                Opposed, nay. The ayes have it. So carried.

                REGULAR AGENDA

                19. DEPARTMENT OF JUVENILE CORRECTIONSJudi Gregory, Human Resources Officer
                  Request for authorization of payment of $100,000 to the surviving spouse of William D. Mann who died in the line of duty on March 12, 2002 in a BOA plane crash. Mr. Mann was a Safety & Security Officer working for the Juvenile Corrections Center in Nampa and was responsible for juveniles in state custody, including during transport from one facility to another.

                20. STATE TAX COMMISSIONDuWayne D. Hammond, Jr., Chairman
                  Request for authorization to transfer $7.5 million from the General Fund into the state refund account such that interest expense will be minimized on any tax returned processed after June 15, 2002, pursuant to Idaho Code 63-3067 (2). The Board approved the transfer of $12 million from the General Fund into the state refund account on June 3, 2002.

                State Controller: Governor, we have two items on the Regular Agenda. The first is from the Juvenile Corrections regarding the payment of a death of a law enforcement official in the plane crash earlier this year in March. I believe that Judi Gregory is here. I guess no one is here from the department but this is the item pursuant to the statute where the correctional officer, pilot and one young person was killed in the plane crash. There has been some question about should there be a payment for the pilot as well as the correctional officer, and it is the recommendation of the department that only the correctional officer’s survivors receive the payment.

                Governor: Discussion? General.

                Attorney General: Governor, J. D., I understand that a line of duty determination was made by ISP and they determined this was in the line of duty. Once again, I think we need to be careful how we handle it so we don’t end up paying about $33,000 in federal taxes. We have been through this before, so subject to that arrangement to insure maximum to the family members I am prepared to support this recommendation.

                Governor: Also, J.D., it is my understanding too they are continuing to review with regard to Jay Morris whether there is any sort of similar program they can use.

                State Controller: Governor, this statute is one that probably ought to be looked at. It is not really clear and could be fixed quite a bit. As to the taxability, I think we received the clarification we needed from the IRS on the prior payments and that will be the standard operating procedure that we will follow from now on.

                Attorney General: I would agree with the Governor and you. I think the statute needs to be looked at because I think there is interpretation out there that if an officer, as an example, were to just drop over from a health problem and expire, that he or she or they would be entitled to $100,000. I don’t think that is what the legislature had in mind when they passed this. I think they were talking about an intervening event other than just health reasons and so forth and so on, and how far we go with it. I think we need some guidance from the legislature to help us a little bit on this thing. Having said all that, I would move for the payment of $100,000 to the family of Mr. Bill Mann.

                Governor: I would second that. Discussion? I would just note that it is a tragedy what happened with the loss of all three lives. A very sad occasion. Further discussion? Those in favor signify by saying aye.

                Aye: Governor
                  Attorney General

                Opposed, nay. The ayes have it. So carried.

                State Controller: Governor, the last item on the agenda, #20, is from the State Tax Commission. I believe Mr. Dewey Hammond, who is the chairman of the Commission, is here to make a request of the Board.

                Governor: Dewey, welcome.

                DuWayne Hammond: Governor, I have a couple people I would like to acknowledge that are present with me, Governor, Mr. Lance and Mr. J.D. Steve Miller handles all our revenue operations division. That might not mean much to you folks but he handles over $1.9 million tax returns a year. And Dana John, who is in charge of all our tax policy area. I would like to acknowledge their presence today. A brief overview – we have had a unique tax drive and there are two unique items that bring us here today. One is an all time record number of refund requests. Over 70.5% of the income tax returns we have received thus far this year are for refunds. Normal is in the mid 60’s, 65 to 66 to 67% and that change amounts to some money. Second item is House Bill 378 that pays personal property taxes for agricultural equipment comes directly off the refund account, and that is $13.4 million on an annual basis. 3.35 per quarter and that has drained this account. Absent the House Bill 378 we would not have made the request of you ten days ago, nor the request today. But we are making the request today, and I have a handout that I would like to share with the members if I may. The first page demonstrates what I have just said. The second page is the flow of funds. Just before we received the $12 million ten days or so ago the balance in the refund account was a negative $11.1 million. With the receipt of $12 million all 35,000 tax returns were processed, paid, put in the mail and received by the taxpayers. In the first five days of June we received – June has an abnormal pattern, well all months have the same pattern, I am trying to say. The first two weeks are relatively low inflow and the last part of the month high inflow when the 20th hits and all the returns, particularly withholding returns come in. That is the pattern. What is unique about June is it wraps up our tax drive, number one. Number two, any refunds not paid on or after June 15 have interest retroactive to April 15.

                Governor: Say that again, please, Dewey.

                DuWayne Hammond: Okay. Any refunds not paid on or after June 15 get interest retroactive back to April 15. And that is the thing we are trying to prevent. If you authorize $7.5 million transfer from the General Fund today we will be able to process all the returns from the tax drive and not have to pay interest. If you say no to that we will have an interest obligation of about $100,000 to $110,000 is our estimate. The sheet flow shows you the flow of funds. In the first five days $710,500 was deposited to the refund account. Netting it all out last Thursday night the balance was $1,586,000 positive. We project, we show you a range of projections of inflow into the account to the 15th, expected refunds that Mr. Miller has to pay, $9.8 million. Then if you authorize this transfer of $7.5 million the balance after all those refunds are paid would be the range indicated. Now comes the relatively heavy deposits from June 15 to 30 ranging between $12.5 and $14.5 million, and then possible refund payments that Mr. Miller would make depending on correspondence back from the taxpayer, etc. They range from $500,000 in the last two weeks of the month up to $2 million. $500,000 in that neighborhood is closer to reality, I think. So the balance before the statutory reversion is between $10 and $14 million. The statute says that anything over $1.5 million on June 30 is reverted so you see our range of reversion estimates. That is it, Governor.

                Governor: So, Dewey, if we follow this through, as you say, the bottom line there is a reversion to General Fund, but you are asking today for $7.5 million extension for a period of how long?

                DuWayne Hammond: If you approve the $7.5 million, all of the refunds will be able to be paid before June 15 without interest. There is no real extension in terms of time as we think of extensions, sir.

                Governor: What I mean is the reversion to the General Fund.

                DuWayne Hammond: That would be on June 30 when we close the books and everything is done.

                Governor: So the General Fund is back to what it had been?

                DuWayne Hammond: Yes. It certainly will be back. All of the $7.5 million, as you can see, would be repaid, but all of the $12 million will not. Let’s assume if the upper end of the range hits $13.5 million minus $7.5 million, so between $6 to $6.5 million of that original borrowing.

                Governor: This is a timing issue.

                DuWayne Hammond: Yes, sir.

                Governor: Also, I think you are to be commended, and Steve Miller, the fact that you got these refunds processed as quickly as you did because I think in April there was an indication that it might be June 15 before you would get all of these done. And yet you really have done some tremendous effort.

                DuWayne Hammond: You asked for them to be returned and Steve turned his folks on and they work almost 24-7. That and the new processing system that you approved several years ago is bringing the returns in faster, and so there has been a lot of effort.

                Governor: Good. Questions? General.

                Attorney General: Dewey, are you going to pay us any interest on this money?

                DuWayne Hammond: No.

                Attorney General: In spite of that I would move approval.

                Governor: It is an interesting question because while we talk about the fact, Dewey, that if we don’t pay by June 15 we have to pay interest, but by withdrawing this from the General Fund there is some interest lost. But I would imagine the net is that, number one, it is beneficial to the taxpayers. I would second the motion. Further discussion? Those in favor please say aye.

                Aye: Governor
                Attorney General

                Opposed, nay.

                Dewey, thank you very much. I think it is telling your statistic there also as you are in the 70% of returns, reflects what has been happening in this economy. Thanks very much, Steve. Thank you for your work. Thank you, Dana. Mr. Controller.

                State Controller: We have two items from the State Insurance Fund relating to the balances in the Insurance Fund and the Petroleum Storage Tank Fund. With that, that concludes the agenda.

                Governor: Anything else to come before us? If not, we stand adjourned.


                  STATE INSURANCE FUND

                21. Estimate of the State Insurance Fund expenses to be paid by sight drafts for the month of May 2002.
                    Estimated expenditure for workers $ 10,000,000.00
                    compensation claim costs, dividends
                    and premium refunds

                  Funds Expended in April 2002:
                    Workers Compensation Claim Costs $ 8,319,900.82
                    Dividend 45,880.22
                    Commissions 5,402.70
                    Policy Refunds 154,833.43
                                        Total $ 8,526,017.17

                22. Estimate of the Petroleum Storage Tank Fund expenses to be paid by sight draft or the month of May 2002.

                    Estimated expenditures for $ 750,000.00
                    Petroleum Storage Tank Fund
                  Fund expended in April 2002:
                    Payroll $ 53,223.72
                    Operations 16,397.78
                    Claim Costs 128,649.52
                    Total $ 198,271.02

                  WHEREUPON THE MEETING OF THE STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS was adjourned, subject to the call of the Chairman.

                                              Governor Dirk Kempthorne
                                              Chairman of the Board

                    J. D. Williams, Secretary of the Board
                    and State Controller
                    Page last updated on 07/12/2006 01:48:42 PM